Showing posts with label first. Show all posts
Showing posts with label first. Show all posts

Thursday, August 14, 2008

News Site Commentary: Public Forum or Flame Bait?

We all like to share our opinions. The United States was founded on this idea, and the founders wanted these opinions to be freely shared. It is because of this that we have the right to disagree, and it is the reason why I can write this blog that you are reading right now.

Comments are useful as it allows us to give back to a news story in a way as well as view the reactions of others in the voyeuristic behavior that is customary of the Western World in this age, but how many times has an intelligent conversation or argument been derailed by a comment that is equally ignorant or vulgar? These sort of postings can turn even the story of the death of a person into a degenerating skirmish of demeaning insults and swear words.

In the end, the benefit of the ability to share one's point of view by commenting on news stories far outweighs the occasional punk on the Internet who decides to go and ruin it for everyone else.

To quote an oldie: "Don't let one bad apple ruin the bunch."

FPD in the Public Eye: Christian Bastion or Country Club?

A recent story on macon.com about three teachers from First Presbyterian Day School returning to work after having children and being stay-at-home moms for several years. While the story in itself is not a major hit, it has sparked a war of commentary about whether or not FPD, and private schools in general, are narrow-minded and stuck-up in relation to their public school counterparts. Seeing this has made me think about how I perceive the school.

While FPD is an academically sound school, its otherwise excellent curriculum is weighed down by Bible courses that, outside of more practical courses such as Comparative Religion, are incredibly repetitive and yield no further information the second, third, and fourth time you take a testament survey course, Genesis course, or Life and Letters of Paul, just to name a few. This is an incredible waste of time in student schedules that instead could be used for another elective, or for a study hall in later grades, when holding a full Honors-AP course load can be a delicate balance, one that can be tipped with the bulk of another rehash Bible course.

The second thing about FPD that blights the nice paint and facilities is how the student body acts towards a variety of things. The most forgivable of these traits is the general lack of knowledgeable interest in real-world issues such as the presidential election, oil prices, and, most recently, the Russian occupation of Georgia, many of whom did not even know was a country, earning strange looks for me when I mentioned Russians taking the capital. The interest of the student body is instead captivated by updates on facebook followed closely by a mixture of sports, dating, and the Jonas Brothers.

Things are less forgivable, however, when minorities come into the picture. Because there are maybe 1 and at most 2 black people in each grade, some of the less-classy of the upper class have free reign in making racist comments in an almost casual demeanor, sometimes directly to a black student, in the comfort that there will be no 'peer justice' from the minority's friends.

Racism may not even be the most severe problem among private schools, but the most apparent and provable for the purpose of this blog. Ironically, problems such as drinking, drug use, and sexual interaction among students, those which parents send a child to private school to protect them from, may not be quite as prevalent and visible as their public school counterparts, but they are present, and this is what matters.

To put this into a single sentence: While the academic environment of First Presbyterian Day School is significantly better than that of nearly all Bibb County public schools, one must be careful not to idealize it as the same problems are present, except hidden under a cloak of dollar bills and khaki pants.